To put names in here, It was Avengedd a good raider but recently a bad attendance record VS. Greatbadgirl(Greatbad's alt who is becoming more his main for G2 and maybe Cata) an Officer with perfect attendance.
Now it was not just Avengedd vs Great there were maybe 4 or 5 other OS rolls Great just got the highest. This item was also put up for bid 3 times, first time no one wanted it, second time Avengedd wanted it but had no DKP. Third time was the final win.
The loot is set and nothing was wrong with the way it was handled.
But for the future we need to know; Can a member go negative for an item that they are bidding on, if the Min bid is greater then there Net DKP VS Offspec rollers. As a side note when we make the change to EPGP this issue will be null as EPGP has a different system to handle this with MS always winning.
On a side note I've been a Loot Whore the last three weeks. For the last 3 weeks I've won a new Wand every week biding my near Max DKP, for these minor Upgrade Wands lol...