So im just jumping in here, I see this point from both perspectives. Honestly, Bash I think that you may be looking straight at the negative and the fact that hes "airing dirty laundry" or whatever you want to call it and not looking at the bigger picture of what he is saying.
I don't see Jesseh saying that we need to make the guild hardcore at all. What he is saying is that people need to be accountable for their actions. For example, Heroic Iskar...after we wipe on that fight for an hour plus to mechanics--the ball, the chakrum, etc. The last think I want to do is go kill something like...mythic hellfire assault. If people cant pay attention to a mechanic where all they have to do is run our or click a button to pass a ball, it does not bode well for learning some of the mechanics in mythic. As well, on reaver (im guilty of it myself), we should be getting out of the cone effect, should have from when we started the fight back on normal, but people are still getting hit by it. Now it does the damage where it fucks the raid. Two or three people get it, its a wipe instantly. So hes not saying to make the guild more hardcore, this guild is as fall from hardcore as there is. What he is saying is that people need to be accountable, sat, had ep taken away, missed out on loot, etc for the mistakes that they cause that fuck the rest of the raid. And while some may think "oh we can carry 1-2 people", we CANT in mythic everyone has to be their part. And in all honestly, I dont want to carry people, that takes the fun out of it when we wipe until we get to the point that we can provide "coverage" for the person that fucked up.
It also means, that people arnt doing everything that they can to improve their toon. Why not take advantage of the free food that was put in the bank? Why do people Still not have their own food. I personally come to raid with my flasks, potions, food, and even feasts. It can also go to having the mats/enchants for gear that may drop or even having the best enchant on your gear available even though you are waiting on a better drop. Its about being prepared to raid and using all the tools available to make your toon better and in return make your boss attempts better.
As a whole, what I get from Jesseh is that hes frustrated and a little bit sad that people are not taking going into mythic seriously. You can still have a good time and do the mechanics and bosses correctly. The things that he is asking for arnt that hard. Raid guilds need to have their raiders give a fuck about their toons.
What needs to be remembered here, is that we are a group and 20ish raiders. We all fail and achieve as a team. Calling each other out for opinions or having negative thoughts will not solve shit. We are not all going to think the same. I think that all a whole, some type of balance does need to be found if we are to continue mythic and that everyone needs to remember that there is not an I in TEAM. Everything one person does effects the other 19 people.
This is MY 2 cents, take it how you will.
Edit: I didnt read to the end, and basically just said what Jesseh said in his last post.